Top 8 Moutherwatering Holiday Meal Replacement Shakes to Try Top 8 Moutherwatering Holiday Meal Replacement Shakes to Try

Nothing screams holiday season and cozy, cold winter weather more than the delicious flavors of gingerbread, hot cocoa, peppermint, eggnog, pumpkin spice, cinnamon, apple pie, and caramel. 

But don’t worry about getting on Santa’s naughty list! With these 8 shakes we’re about to show you, you can experience all of these mouthwatering holiday flavors and still stick to your keto or healthy weight loss diet.

Here are 8 of our favorite shakes that pack all the nutrition with none of the guilt, sure to make your holidays merry and bright: 

1) 310 Gingerbread

310, our #1 top-rated shake of 2021, has captured the warm, spicy flavor of the holiday season in their 310 Gingerbread Shake. This Limited Holiday Edition flavor features ginger, cinnamon, and clove nestled in with creamy hints of vanilla. Enjoy this velvety-rich goodness on its own or add to your steaming latte for an extra healthy holiday treat.  

What we love about 310: This #1 shake has NO sugar or artificial sweeteners. Plus all their shakes are keto and paleo-friendly, GMO-free, gluten, and dairy-free, and are complete with high-quality plant-based proteins and prebiotics.

Here’s what 310 customers are saying about this flavor:

“I absolutely love the taste of this Gingerbread 310 shake. So yummy with coconut milk and oats!!” – Aimee P. 

“The gingerbread has such a rich, delicious flavor. Definitely reminds me of the holidays. It blends well with almond milk and is very filling. I recommend this flavor for sure!” – Christina V.

“LOVE the gingerbread shake.” – Stephanie M. 

2) Orgain Peppermint Hot Cocoa

Nothing says happy holidays like a scrumptious and minty peppermint holiday shake! Grab your candy cane and enjoy Orgain’s limited-edition holiday flavor featuring 21 grams of organic, plant-based protein and no added sugar. 

What we love about Orgain: All flavors contain a plethora of organic superfoods like blueberries and sprouted quinoa that are great for your health.

Here’s what Orgain customers are saying about this flavor:

“I am using this in place of my coffee creamer and it is so yummy. Can’t wait for Black Friday sales to get more!!” – Jaclyn B. 

“Christmas in a cup! Tastes great!” – Nikki L.

“I absolutely love hot chocolate in the fall and the winter. This is the best replacement, just add heavy whipping cream and you’re golden. Don’t forget the marshmallows!”- Amelia C. 

3) Keto Chow Eggnog

Just like the classic holiday favorite, Keto Chow Eggnog is supremely creamy and lightly spiced with nutmeg. Only with this eggnog, you can skip the unhealthy fats and high calories while sticking to your keto diet! But make sure to get this one before the holidays are over because their seasonal flavor is only available in the fall and winter.

What we love about Keto Chow: All Keto Chow flavors feature ultra-low carbohydrates designed to put the body into nutritional ketosis. It’s a great high-protein and gluten-free supplement for those following a keto diet.

Here’s what Keto Chow customers are saying about this flavor:

“Eggnog Keto Chow is delicious. Love the creamy eggnog taste. One of my favorites!” – Mary Mockerman

“I used to love eggnog, and have missed it since going keto. This flavor is a wonderful option for my new lifestyle. I love mine with unsalted butter, and my daughter makes hers with heavy whipping cream. Such a delight.” – Jennifer Sweet 

“Great taste. One of my go-to flavors each order.” – Shawn Slanker

4) 310 Pumpkin Spice

Treat your tastebuds to the comforting flavors of 310’s Pumpkin Spice, reminiscent of your favorite fall and winter holidays. Rich, creamy-tasting pumpkin swirls with an iconic blend of flavors like vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger. As crave-worthy as freshly baked pumpkin pie or your favorite latte, without the sugar or high calories.

What we love about 310: This #1 shake has NO sugar or artificial sweeteners. Plus all their shakes are keto and paleo-friendly, GMO-free, gluten, and dairy-free, and are complete with high-quality plant-based proteins and prebiotics.

Here’s what 310 customers are saying about this flavor:

“Love the pumpkin spice, chocolate, and vanilla. I drink one or two daily. Great product.” – Teresa V.

“I had to order 2 bags of the pumpkin spice meal replacement shake!! The quality and taste are AMAZING. One scoop is the perfect amount. It’s like dessert for dinner! I love it! Add some peanut butter or chocolate and it’s amazing.” – Christina M.

“I love the pumpkin spice shake. Creamy, thick, and delicious. Mixes well with almond milk. Sometimes I substitute this as creamer for my coffee.” – Sheila C. 

5) LadyBoss Lean Cinnamon Roll

With this LadyBoss Lean Cinnamon Roll flavor, you can enjoy the delicious cinnamon scent of the holidays but without the guilt of all that added sugar. Plus this powder is super easy to add to your favorite holiday shakes, baked goods, breakfast, and dessert recipes! Or, savor it in your coffee, latte, or hot chocolate to stay warm and cozy in these cold winter months. 

What we love about LadyBoss Lean: Fans rave about how awesome these shakes taste, literally “like cake”, while providing good protein, vitamins, and minerals.

Here’s what LadyBoss Lean customers are saying about this flavor:

“To my surprise, the sample of Cinnamon Roll Lean was not overly strong on the cinnamon. The shake was not too sweet with a light taste of butter, cinnamon, and even a hint of frosting on top. I cannot wait to try this in warm oatmeal. Drooling just at the thought of that!” – Michelle N.

“Holy cinnamon!! The smell is amazing. Smells just like a cinnamon roll. If you like Cinnamon Cereal and Donut Lean, you’re going to love Cinnamon Roll. It is a perfect mix of the two. Super creamy and not too sweet.” – Renne L.

“I think I died and went to Lean heaven!! Cinnamon Roll is my favorite breakfast and I’m so excited! I am absolutely in love and I just want more.” – Tara J.

6) 310 Peppermint Swirl

We hope you’re in the mood for peppermint because we can’t get enough of it this holiday season! One sip of 310’s blissfully sweet, vanilla-peppermint shake will thoroughly delight your senses and awaken your taste buds. With a rich and creamy vanilla profile, their shake features the ideal amount of refreshing peppermint and makes an amazing addition to holiday smoothies, lattes, baked goods, and more.

What we love about 310: This #1 shake has NO sugar or artificial sweeteners. Plus all their shakes are keto and paleo-friendly, GMO-free, gluten, and dairy-free, and are complete with high-quality plant-based proteins and prebiotics.

Here’s what 310 customers are saying about this flavor:

“Love the peppermint with my coconut milk and a little mocha.” – Nora D.

“I use almond milk, one-half of a small banana, and a lot of ice in mine. Sometimes I add a teaspoon of unsweetened Hershey’s cocoa. I love it! It’s one of my favorite 310 flavors.” – Anne E.

“It’s the yummiest! I will be buying more for the holidays.” – Valerie G. 

7) Keto Chow Apple Pie

This keto-friendly flavor is perfect for those chilly winter nights when you’re craving a slice of warm apple pie. With hints of apple and lightly-spiced with your favorite fall flavors including cinnamon, cardamom, and nutmeg, this shake will taste just like the real thing. Only it’s guilt-free and keto-friendly, making this Keto Chow flavor an easy holiday favorite. 

What we love about Keto Chow: All Keto Chow flavors feature ultra-low carbohydrates designed to put the body into nutritional ketosis. It’s a great high-protein and gluten-free supplement for those following a keto diet.

Here’s what Keto Chow customers are saying about this flavor:

“Yum! Apple Pie Keto Chow is one of my favorites. I’m glad I bought the big bag because it’s one I crave most often. I generally mix it with cream, but sometimes a little butter and cinnamon too.” –  Heather M.

“For me, the Apple Pie flavor is perfect. It has just the right blend of spices and apple flavor to really hit the sweet spot for me.” – Laura F.

“Love, love the apple pie Keto Chow. Satisfies my craving for a fattening apple pie shake all while being very low carb and healthy.” – Christine G.

8) 1UP Caramel Toffee Macchiato

This 1Up flavor is like a fall or winter seasonal Starbucks drink, only you can enjoy this low-calorie and zero sugar shake guilt-free! With its silky-smooth and lightly-sweet caramel texture and taste, this flavor is the perfect addition to your holiday baking. Or, enjoy on its own over ice or in your steaming cup of coffee. 

What we love about 1UP: Founded by fitness enthusiasts, 1UP is perfect for energy-boosting and muscle stamina before and after your workout. Plus their ingredients are from high-quality sources, with customers complimenting their taste and texture. 

Here’s what 1UP customers are saying about this flavor:

“Perfect taste, especially if you have a sweet tooth like me.” – Ivette A.

“I’ve bought other vegan protein and they taste weird and the texture is thick. 1UP vegan protein tastes so good! It’s not thick or anything like that, very smooth and delicious… Definitely going to keep on taking it.” – Sarai S.

“This protein is so delicious! I ordered the Caramel Toffee Macchiato flavor and I have it in a smoothie with PB & Banana for dessert every day. It blends so well, even with just water/milk too. It’s the least grainy texture vegan protein I’ve ever had. I will definitely reorder and try new flavors!” – Lauren L. 

Well, that’s a wrap! Are you ready to enjoy one of these delicious holiday flavors yourself? Check out our in-depth diet shake reviews now to learn more about each of them, and how to make your holidays (and your goals) even brighter. 

Compare Popular Shakes Side By Side